Tuesday, 24 February 2009

Cue backlash...

Tory Bear has written a comment piece about the recent farcical student protests for the Edinburgh newspaper

The Journal
. It seems he has already "tickled a few trouts" even though the article has only been up for a few hours.
"When a dozen or so students stormed their campus, university officials cut the power, wifi and access to loos. They refused to negotiate, and very soon the whole thing began to fizzle out. That was New York University. The reaction at Edinburgh was a very different affair, one that has left the reputation of the university tarred and set a worrying precedent. A strange phenomenon has spread from campus to campus this term in the form of a small bunch of well organised, well equipped and well out of line protesters illegally occupying various buildings across American and European universities. The general model for these sit-ins has been the same: get in there, take some photos, set up a blog and watch the chaos ensue as you block thousands of students from receiving the education for which they are paying. How much these protests have actually achieved is open for debate. Last time I checked I don't think the Israeli government was considering a radical change in policy based on twenty-odd students, a guitar and the "creative space" they made for themselves to change the world in.

When the George Square Theatre was occupied last week, it at first seemed that the university was giving tacit consent to the actions of the protesters. They kept the wifi on, allowing them to pump their thinly disguised anti-Zionist thought across the world via their website and Flickr. This really was a 21st century protest, as the glimpse into their press operation showed. I wonder what the protesters of '68 would have thought about sitting around drinking herbal tea while furiously typing into your Mac and checking the Blackberry. The university even opted to keep the heating on, fearing that because of health and safety laws, the building had to be kept above a certain temperature. "

You can read the rest of the article
here
.

The Journal's normally semi-level headed leader writer seems to have a
wee dig
at TB for unduly criticising these protesters, but it's hardly unfair to raise the point that real hippies don't have Macs and Blackberries. (The evidence of which was strangely recently removed from their
website
.) Whatever you want to call them, be it champagne swampies, eco-rahs, or middle class idiots throwing their toys out of the pram while pretending to be oh-so-bleeding-heart socialists, they deserve to be ridiculed. They might have tried to hide it but luckily TB saved the evidence for just this occasion:
Though it has been temptestuous in the past, TB is beginning to enjoy the relationship he has with The Journal. Though they were
far from helpful
during his own
delve
into the horrible world of
student politics
, and every week less than fair to friends, he does enjoy banter like this and the platform for
upsetting
lefties. They have been in financial trouble recently and had to be bailed out by the student's association for office space for the next year, after they couldn't make the rent and get an edition out. While it would be a shame to see the entrepreneurial venture go under, news is reaching TB this morning that there might be further trouble for the team...

Details are sketchy but Tory Bear understands the ball is in motion for legal action to be bought against the paper by an Edinburgh student.

+++developing+++

8 comments:

Paul Nizhinsky
said...

I've applied for a number of London unis this year and I can't help wondering, head in hands, what I've gotten myself in for!

I suppose ridicule and 'lefty-baiting' is the only rational recourse when confronted with such poor, deluded and heart-breakingly well-off souls. They really are rediculous.

Hey-ho, good on you TB!

Morus
said...

"George Square Occupation: PHYRRIC Victory?"

Excuse me? 'Phyrric'? They don't by any chance mean 'Pyrrhic', do they? The term relating to the Pyrrhic War, won at great cost to the victor (and thus making the headline guilty only of laughabe hyperbole, rather than editorial laziness whilst on grammar safari)? Could that be what was meant?

Not having obvious spelling errors in your headlines used to be the sort of standard too low to be formally acknowledged on our student newspapers. Maybe that's why Nouse and Vision (York) were award-winning, and the Journal is going broke.

Shrinking newspaper budgets are no excuse for lack of a dictionary in the editor's office. It's called a false-economy.

If these people had the incessant readership feedback loop that bloggers have to endure/enjoy, they wouldn't be quite so lax, I suspect.

Heavens above.

Matt MacLeod
said...

Hi Morus,

Due to our frantic scrabbling to put the paper to press we haven't yet had the chance to fix it on the website, but the error was picked up and corrected in print, and is now fixed on the site too.

If you'd like to help us catch these errors earlier, you're more than welcome to drop in and help out... As you're aware, we're all volunteers and unfortunately these things sometimes slip through.

-Matt

Morus
said...

Matt McLeod,

I'm sorry. I was in a snarky mood for reasons completely unrelated to politics or the blogosphere, and was being completely unfair and rude.

Had I been aware that you were volunteers (not that such a consideration stops my readers being snarky) I like to think I would have been less uncharitable.

Sincere apologies.

MORUS

Tom FD said...

Does this mean TB is abandoning anonymity?

Anonymous said...

You'll like this tb.

Matt Wardman
said...

Agree with you, but you have to admit that you sound a bit like Mr Suburb...

Occupier said...

I think you'll find the students participating were their in solidarity with not only the people of Palestine who have suffered great suffering, but any populace who have been subject to acts of violence. Yeah, maybe 50 students in a lecture theatre isn't going to change the world, but we did something and I hope that people in Palestine who heard about our and other University occupations found some comfort in the fact that people genuinely care about the atrocities that are happening right now in Gaza.
As Desmond Tutu said: “If you are neutral in situations of injustice, you have chosen the side of the oppressor. If an elephant has its foot on the tail of a mouse and you say that you are neutral, the mouse will not appreciate your neutrality.” So I'm glad I was part of the occupation and that I stood up for injustice rather than sitting at home blogging!

Post a Comment